Elevating Investment Standards: The Labor Department’s Rule and Rollover Recommendations.

The Labor Department’s Rule and Rollover has introduced a new rule set to revolutionize the guidance investors receive regarding rolling over funds from 401(k) plans to individual retirement accounts (IRAs), according to legal experts.

Issued on April 23, the rule, dubbed the “fiduciary” rule, aims to elevate the standards for brokers, financial advisors, and insurance agents providing retirement investment advice. The agency highlights that such recommendations may currently be compromised by conflicts of interest.

Katrina Berishaj, an attorney at Stradley Ronon Stevens & Young, emphasized that rollovers are a central focus of this regulation. “The Department of Labor has made this abundantly clear,” said Berishaj, who serves as co-chair of the firm’s fiduciary governance group.

Every year, millions of investors engage in rollovers, a common practice, especially among those nearing retirement. Typically, this involves transferring savings from a 401(k)-type plan to an IRA. In 2022 alone, Americans rolled over approximately $779 billion from workplace retirement plans to IRAs, as per analysis by the Council of Economic Advisers. IRS data from 2020 indicates that nearly 5.7 million individuals made IRA rollovers. With more baby boomers transitioning into retirement, the frequency and value of these transactions have notably increased. For instance, in 2010, about 4.3 million people rolled over a total of $300 billion to IRAs.

Looking ahead, Katrina Berishaj noted, “If the past is any indication of the future, we can anticipate millions of rollovers each year.” Given the substantial sums involved—potentially hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars per household—rollovers have become a significant policy concern for Labor Department officials and experts alike. Moreover, with Americans living longer, ensuring that savings last for extended periods has become crucial.

The new rule from the Labor Department also extends to advice regarding transferring IRA assets between financial institutions, according to Fred Reish, a partner at Faegre Drinker Biddle & Reath. In 2022, more than 55 million U.S. households, approximately four in ten, owned IRAs, according to data from the Investment Company Institute.

A significant transformation in rollover advice is underway with the introduction of the new Labor Department rule, aiming to imbue more investment recommendations with a fiduciary essence.

In essence, being a fiduciary entails a legal obligation for financial professionals to prioritize their clients’ interests. They are required to offer advice that is both prudent and loyal, while being truthful and charging reasonable fees, according to experts.

Currently, many rollover recommendations do not adhere to a fiduciary standard under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), as attorneys have noted. This lack of fiduciary duty raises concerns among Labor officials about potential conflicts of interest, where advice may prioritize earning brokers higher commissions over what’s best for the investor.

The existing legal framework, dating back to the mid-1970s, outlines five criteria that must be met for a financial agent to be deemed a fiduciary. However, one of these criteria states that fiduciary status applies if advice is provided on a regular basis, which often doesn’t align with the nature of rollover recommendations. These recommendations are typically singular occurrences rather than part of an ongoing advisory relationship, according to attorneys.

As a result, it is uncommon for rollover recommendations to currently adhere to a fiduciary standard, as Fred Reish highlighted. However, the new Labor Department rule changes this paradigm. “Under this rule, one-time investment advice to roll assets out of a plan would trigger fiduciary status under ERISA,” stated Berishaj, emphasizing this shift as a significant one.Why rollover advice may be ‘higher-quality.

The Labor Department’s Rule and Rollover :

The new rule stipulates that advisors should generally explore alternatives to rollovers, considering factors such as the advantages and disadvantages of retaining funds in a 401(k) plan, as highlighted by Berishaj. This might involve comparing fees, expenses, services, and investment options between the workplace plan and an IRA. Prior to recommending a rollover, advisors are expected to furnish investors with disclosures detailing the rationale behind their recommendation.

While reputable advisors strive to act in their clients’ best interests, Reish expressed hope that the Labor Department’s rule would elevate the standard of advice across the industry. He believes the rule aims to promote higher-quality guidance, ultimately leading to improved investment outcomes and reduced costs for investors.

However, not all financial companies endorse the necessity of the Labor Department’s rule. Susan Neely, president and CEO of the American Council of Life Insurers, contends that the regulation will adversely affect retirement savers’ access to professional financial guidance. Neely argues that recent regulations issued by the Securities and Exchange Commission and National Association of Insurance Commissioners have already strengthened consumer protections, suggesting that the Labor Department rule imposes a more rigorous standard.

Reish concurs, noting that the Labor Department rule surpasses the requirements of other regulatory measures. This discrepancy is particularly pronounced in recommendations made by insurance agents regarding rollovers to annuities held in IRAs, owing to disparities between current legal standards and those outlined by the Labor Department.

Jaret Seiberg, a financial services analyst for TD Cowen Washington Research Group, predicts that industry groups will likely challenge the rule through legal action to impede its implementation. 

More info